by Garth Ennis and Leandro Fernandez
*warning this whole thing is one long spoiler
Now on to my probably my favourite book of all time, Up Is Down Black Is
White, I know this book so well I haven’t even bothered reading it before I did
this review.
The story starts with Frank doing a routine gang bust/slaughter afterwards
he goes to a diner to have some food and he finds someone has dug up his family
and pissed on their skeletons via CNN, who seem to have the thing on 24 hour
repeat. while this happening O'Brien (last seen in the beginning being shot and
horny) is enjoying her jail time when 3 prison lesbians try to frame her for a prison
guards death because she won’t go down on them so she has to escape. meanwhile
we find out that it was Nicky Cavella (also from in the beginning) who has set
the whole thing up so he can be the Godfather of the mob, as you can imagine
Frank isn’t too happy and goes on a killing spree of the underworld so massive
it makes the Rwandan genocide look like a picnic for the elderly. so he goes
from gang to gang only leaving one survivor with the message to the police if
they don’t rebury his family then he will just keep killing and they cave
faster than a priest at an all boys school because they are getting so much
shit from the press and criminals who are shitting themselves that they will be
next. When the his family are reburied Castle goes after Cavella who is waiting with a
hit squad including Rawlins from Mother Russia who has been told to kill Castle
on the orders of that general who Fury kicked the shit out of other. Just as
Rawlins is about to shoot the Punisher,O’Brien ambushes him and shoots Cavella in the
chest, causing the Punisher to snap out the funk he's in and letting him make a getaway,
so she rescues frank and kidnaps Rawlins (what a woman) taking him back to Roth’s
so she can torture him for every bit of black market info they can get out of him. They take care of Cavella after being ambushed by Pittsy's
little brother I mean sister and warn him not to go near Rawlins because even
in his half dead state he's still dangerous. It all ends nicely with Rawlins
killing Roth and escaping, O’Brien going on the run and Cavella dying a slow
painful death in a forest allowing Frank to get closure on the whole thing and go
back to killing at his normal speed.

Just a dream
I hadn’t really gotten into The Punisher at this point in my life so I had no idea what
I was picking up when I was browsing through the random issues at the comic
book store, but I got to the end of issue two and that speech kicked in, the one where
he's killed all the gangsters and he turns his guns on the innocence with the
line "if my world ends so does yours" that one line changed how I
viewed not just comic book heroes but heroes in general. Heroes can kill, not only can they kill they can torture you, and it’s weird this concept isn’t a new one we've just been conditioned to think that heroes have that line they should never cross, all our saints and historical figures all their victories and notoriety is bathed in the blood of the people they murdered and killed all in the name of our country, we just gave them some disturbed notion of honour because well do you really want to see the men that enslaved nations as bad people. History remembers them as good that all that matters. We view these
characters like angels holier than holy they can do no wrong, and this guy just
turns the whole thing on its head, it breaks convention at its very heart. It was just a complete shock to me, like that first time you watch the
ending of Fight Club with the sky scrapers crumbling to the ground, it was like
time slowed down panel by panel in these two pages and your just sitting there in shock at what you've witnessed. Wolverine might be damaged
but these was always a line he never dreamed of crossing because at his heart
no matter how much he wanted to be an animal he would never give into it, Frank
Castle on the other hand is that monster, that darkness, it’s so much a part of
him he can barely even see the light he just knows it these guiding him.
The way Fernandez and Ennis have dragged you into someones darkest personal hell and still have you connecting to Frank is just something to behold, watching a character that far gone, the way he is compulsed to do and carry out the kill even though he
knows it will end badly for him. He know there will be serious consequences but
he needs to do it, there’s something in that you can relate to, how many times
have you did something that you know will fuck you over but you do it anyway? It’s
like its saying something brutally honest about human nature, some dark impulse
where you have to make to prove your point even at the expense of something you
love or your health, like walking away from a relationship, it hurts like fuck
but it’s just something you have to do. In this case what happens to Castle was
like opening a meat grinder on to the world, and it wasn’t going to stop till
it was fed, writhing on the floor choking on its own bile and vomit.
what the hell did I drink last night?
What happens to Cavella also brings up some great issues of whether someone
is born a psychopath or can be groomed to be like it, all the horrifying crap
in his childhood is brutally realised in this, there’s the old argument that
child abuse creates mental health issues but before any of that has even
happened he's already murdered his whole family guided by his monster of an
aunt who pretty much kills any chance of a childhood he had, does it excuse all
the forcing a man to eat his sons or digging up a family and pissing on them?
probably not no matter how much sympathy you want to give them but it was
interesting having at least some reasoning behind his behaviour rather than
just making him a flat out two dimensional psycho.
This book is full of strong women Pittsy’s sister makes less of an impact than
her brother but he was going to be a hard act to follow, she's very well drawn
and you can tell they had a specific person in mind when Fernandez drew her if
I didn’t know any better I swear he drew one of the girls I went to school with
(hence the reason I didn’t get laid a lot in my teenage years Crufts wouldn’t
take them for being too dog like) she has a dominating presence and a face that
says 'I will rip off your balls because you don’t have any' it’s a good analogy
because she is just a dog on a leash waiting Cavella’s command to attack
anything he clicks his fingers at, you get the feeling she could have had more
of a story but dies before she gets beyond the love sick puppy routine, which
is a shame I wouldn’t have minded an issue where her and barracuda team up.
Another strong woman Obrien is just a powerhouse in this, the way she’s the
only one in the whole book she seems to have her head straight apart from the
fact she acts like a love sick school girl with a wet on for the punisher, she
does do the whole sensitive thing but it’s a good reflection of how fucked up
the punishers world is, there’s a sadness in her, a wish fulfilment that things
could have been different for them but at the same time resigns herself to the
fact there is no other way of life for people like her or Castle.
worst threesome ever
As with most of the MAX series the art is a highlight but Fernandez truly out does himself in this book, the whole thing is almost played out in black and white, giving the effect that your reading the whole thing from a darkened room and the few shades of light you do get normally come from a gun shot. There are lots of detailed close ups of characters grimacing the only time you ever see anyone smile in this is when they have done something evil, you can see clearly what each person is thinking that you could get by without dialogue.
I could talk about this book all day if you give me the chance, every page,
panel and word is as near perfect as you’re ever going to get in any comic you
will ever read, if that isn’t enough for you to pick it up you've obviously been fucking
your aunty.